Welcome!

Welcome! Here we publish our views on new research and insights from the field of pulmonary medicine, most often focusing on topics related to exercise, nutrition, and other self-management techniques for those who suffer from chronic shortness of breath.

Whether you have COPD, currently smoke, or are just concerned about persistent shortness of breath and/or cough, read our articles to explore COPD treatment options and self-management techniques that can help you feel better NOW!



Monday, January 18, 2010

New Medicare Rules Now In Effect for Pulmonary Rehab – A Mixed Blessing


In a blend of good news and bad news, Medicare enacted new rules for the reimbursement of pulmonary rehabilitation services effective on January 1, 2010.


For the respiratory care professionals who have lobbied long and hard for changes in how Medicare (and ultimately other health insurers) reimburses practitioners for providing pulmonary rehab services, there is a measure of satisfaction that some progress was made in the new reimbursement rules. On the other hand, the degree to which these dedicated pulmonary physicians and therapists have had to fight in order to get a handful of modest changes enacted has surely been frustrating.


To take a step back, it is important to understand that pulmonary rehabilitation as a practice has been fighting for reimbursement recognition for a very long time. This is mostly due to the fact that there are few "hard data" measurements to demonstrate successful patient outcomes in pulmonary rehabilitation. In this profession, practitioners typically use results of six minute walk tests and patient quality of life surveys to measure patient improvement from admission into a program to graduation (both in research studies and clinical evaluations). Since most of the patients they see have developed irreversible lung damage anyway, the best respiratory professionals can do is help people feel better and better manage their conditions (and if patients stick with it after formal rehab, slow the progression of lung disease and reduce the incidence of future shortness of breath attacks). There is unfortunately no current diagnostic/statistical measure that one could look at and say pulmonary rehab definitively improved Patient X's lung function.


But insurers, including Medicare, want to make certain that they reimburse practitioners only for services that produce a verifiable improvement in patients' health (understandably so). While the body of scientific evidence of pulmonary rehab's effectiveness using the above two measures is substantial and impressive, they are not the same sort of statistics that insurers prefer to validate patient outcomes. Despite this bias, over the last two decades, respiratory care professionals have opened Medicare's minds enough to these measures as descriptive of patient outcome to achieve insurance reimbursement.

So what's changed in the new Medicare rules and how will these changes help people interested in pursuing pulmonary rehab?

Though there were a host of changes in the new ruling the two most important changes enacted in terms of broadening access to pulmonary rehab were as follows:
  • A single, nationwide reimbursement category for pulmonary rehabilitation services was established that covers most of the core elements of pulmonary rehab services (known in Medicare speak as a National Coverage Determination). Prior to this change, there was no central, nationwide reimbursement standard/amount for providing pulmonary rehab services. Practitioners had to utilize an array of individual codes for specific services performed during pulmonary rehab sessions and these codes varied from region to region in the U.S. (known as a Local Coverage Determinations). It was cumbersome to track/report on all of those codes and not all pulmonary rehab services were covered. As a side effect of the previous reimbursement situation, many hospitals today do not offer pulmonary rehab services given the combination of coding hassle factor and how low reimbursement levels are compared to the cost of providing these services. 
For your information, the amount that practitioners can be reimbursed for a 1-hour rehab session under the new rule is $50. When you consider the cost of outfitting and staffing a pulmonary rehab facility (doctors, therapists, medical equipment, exercise equipment, physical space), this is a very modest sum – but it's a lot better than Medicare's original proposed amount of $19/hour! 

Prior to the reimbursement rule change, practitioners could be reimbursed in 15 minute increments of $18 for certain specific/discreet services. So if a practitioner conducted an hour long session that was comprised of 4 reimbursable services, they received $72. As a result, the new all-encompassing reimbursement rate is less than stringing together four individual pulmonary rehab services in a one hour session but at least the new reimbursement category doesn't involve the same amount of hassle in coding/tracking the incremental services and it covers a broader array of services (though a slew of new cumbersome requirements were created to assess patient progress in order to achieve reimbursement under the new rule). By the way, practitioners can still utilize the Local Coverage Determinations if they want to continue to seek reimbursement as they have in the past (and our guess is that many will).
  • The number of allowable reimbursed sessions/patient increased from 36 1-hour sessions to 72 1-hour sessions. This allows practitioners to offer a longer course of pulmonary rehab, and/or to provide a maintenance program after patients complete their initial core program. This is a pretty big change. It essentially allows practitioners the ability to double the amount of pulmonary rehab offered to patients. In the past, when a patient had exhausted his/her insurance/Medicare coverage, they graduated and were expected to continue pulmonary rehab on their own or at their own expense. Knowing that it takes more than a few weeks to solidify a lasting commitment to new health habits, this is a very welcome improvement.
     
Sounds like a pretty good deal right? Well, yes and no. There is at least one really big remaining shortcoming of the way pulmonary rehab services are reimbursed:


Pulmonary rehab services covered by this new Medicare National Coverage Determination are extended only to COPD patients and limits reimbursement to those patients identified as Moderate to Severe (known in the medical profession as Stage II and Stage III COPD). In other words, the new reimbursement rules do NOT cover pulmonary rehab services for nearly any other lung condition nor for patients who have either Mild or Very Severe COPD.


Folks, the reality is pulmonary rehab is an effective treatment for ANYONE who experiences chronic shortness of breath - whether or not you have been diagnosed with COPD or some other form of lung disease/condition (and in our opinion, even if you are a smoker who has yet to be diagnosed with any lung disease but are concerned about chronic or persistent shortness of breath).

The cruel irony of the way that pulmonary rehab services are offered and reimbursed is that you have to be "Goldilocks" to get access to a program that is reimbursed by insurers. You can't be too sick (ala Very Severe COPD) and you can't be too healthy (ala mild COPD) and you can't have nearly any other lung disease other than COPD.


The sad part of this situation is that it is clear that the less lung damage you have when you begin a pulmonary rehab style program, the better off you will be if you stick with such a program. If you already have lung disease, the earlier in the development of your condition you start and maintain such a program, the better chance you have of slowing the progression of lung disease.


From a health care cost standpoint, beginning and maintaining a pulmonary rehab style program earlier in the development of lung disease would lower the number and duration of future hospitalizations associated with COPD and quite likely reduce the need for medications and oxygen therapy (neither of which do anything but relieve short term symptoms) – all very costly medical services that far exceed the cost of providing pulmonary rehab to a wider audience of people who suffer from chronic shortness of breath!

And so while the new Medicare rules are a demonstrative step in the right direction, there is still a significant amount of more work to do to get pulmonary rehab into the lives of more people for whom it can make a substantial difference in how they feel and live.

Wednesday, January 6, 2010

Can nutritional supplements help people with breathing difficulties?

The broad answer to this question is…maybe. While there have been a number of studies conducted globally about the effectiveness of certain nutrients in improving various aspects of health for COPD patients and other pulmonary conditions, it would be a significant stretch to say there is consensus in the medical community about their usefulness.


Most often, respiratory care professionals point to the lack of multiple, large studies confirming effectiveness of certain supplements as their primary objection to advocating a particular supplement. This is a reasonable objection that is the primary weakness of the vast majority of the research done in the nutritional supplement field.


Since nutritional supplements are by and large commodity products, individual supplement manufacturers/marketers are generally not willing to fund large studies on their own when positive results published from their studies can be immediately used by their competitors to market competitive products. There are exceptions of course. Some ingredients can be patented, and some uses of combined ingredients can be patented, but for the most part there is no intellectual property protection for commonly found ingredients in food. Hence, investments in large scale supplement studies generally does not happen – at least on the scale physicians are used to seeing invested in pharmaceutical studies. As a result, the supplement studies do not carry the same credibility as pharma studies within the pulmonology profession. That all said…


In our opinion, it is worth your investment of time to learn about some of these supplement studies because some of the results are impressive even though the studies are small. We give you one example here and we will write of others as we find ones worthy of your attention:

In 2006, a group of Brazilian researchers investigated whether adding the nutritional supplement L-Carnitine would provide a noticeable benefit to COPD patients undergoing a pulmonary rehabilitation exercise program.


L-Carnitine is an amino acid used in the human body to facilitate energy production (it acts as a carrier of fatty acids to the mitochondria in muscle cells where energy to move muscles is produced). It has been shown in other studies to produce a noticeable effect in exercise tolerance in populations with nutritional or muscular deficiency but had never been previously studied in COPD patients to the best knowledge of the researchers. The free full text of the study can be found by clicking here.


In this study, the researchers split 16 moderate to severe COPD patients into two groups – a carnitine group that received 2 grams of L-Carnitine daily for 6 weeks, and a placebo group that received a placebo pill for the same period of time. During this six week period, both groups exercised on a treadmill for 30 minutes a day, three days a week at identical workload levels. Both groups' physical conditioning and vital health statistics were evaluated before and after the six week period.


While both the placebo group and the carnitine group experienced notable improvements in their physical conditioning and vital health statistics due primarily to the benefits received from the exercise program, the carnitine group's improvement notably outstripped the placebo group.


The researchers concluded the carnitine group's higher level of improvements in conditioning and vital health statistic measures were driven by the addition of L-Carnitine, "The main results of the present study show the beneficial effects of L-carnitine supplementation in enhancing physiological responses at identical levels of exercise, reducing lactate concentration, improving exercise tolerance and inspiratory muscle strength in COPD".


The study measured relative performance between the two groups in distance walked at peak speed, distanced walked in six minutes, heart rate at peak speed & same speed, blood pressure, blood lactate production, and other physiological measures. In all cases, the carnitine group outperformed the placebo group.


The researchers acknowledged that one of the weaknesses of their study is its small sample size (16 subjects). Does this invalidate the results? No, but it doesn't get American Thoracic Society to offer an endorsement of L-Carnitine (rightly so, until others can replicate the findings, hopefully in larger studies).


Despite this, should you try L-Carnitine if you are a COPD patient and are trying to start or maintain an exercise program? Read the full study at the link provided above and judge for yourself. Presuming you've checked with your doctor to ensure that there are no counter-indications with medications you currently take, we think it is worth considering.


If instead you'd like to find food sources containing high amounts of L-Carnitine, the highest sources are found in the meat of lamb and sheep (mutton) but you'd have to consume a lot of lamb/mutton each day to yield 2 grams of L-Carnitine…2 lbs. of mutton or 5.6 lbs. of lamb each day!

Monday, January 4, 2010

New Study Reinforces the Benefit of Sticking With Pulmonary Rehab Practices after Graduating From an Outpatient Program


A French study published in December 2009 revealed that COPD patients who continued exercising and receiving education/support through an informal maintenance program after a formal pulmonary rehab program demonstrated significant improvements in exercise tolerance, perceived shortness of breath and self-reported quality of life.

In my mind this study reinforces the need for more proactive efforts by the medical community to educate COPD patients (and pre-COPD patients for that matter) about the power of pulmonary rehab and to provide greater ongoing access for these patients to continue their own "maintenance" program at home, a fitness center or other appropriate venue after graduating from an outpatient program. The more pulmonary rehabilitation access, education and guidance COPD patients receive and the longer they receive this combination, the better they feel and perform. Plain and simple.

It is one of the main reasons I created the Breathe Better for Life guide/CD (click here to learn more) – to put the knowledge of the principles and practices of pulmonary rehabilitation in the hands of people who struggle to breathe so they have a fighting chance of maintaining or improving how they feel throughout their lifetime. It's also why I continue to investigate and develop new pulmonary rehab tools, technology and publishing products - to help the medical community meet this clearly growing need.

In this particular study, the research team led by Gregory Moullec and G. Minot at the University of Montpellier in Montpellier, France, set out to determine whether COPD patients graduating from a typical pulmonary rehab program would maintain or increase conditioning benefits and quality of life survey scores by continuing the practices and principles learned in the pulmonary rehab program (Moullec G, Minot G. An integrated programme after pulmonary rehabilitation in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: effect on emotional and functional dimensions of quality of life. Clin Rehabil Online. December 21, 2009). Full text of the study is available for purchase by clicking here.

In doing so, the researchers first screened moderate to severe COPD patients and yielded 27 subjects who completed the study. All 27 patients went through an intensive 4 week outpatient pulmonary rehab program (20 sessions over the 4 week period). After graduation, they split their study group of 27 COPD patients into two different panels. In one group, 16 graduating COPD patients were provided what the researchers deemed "usual after care". In short, this group received a letter upon graduation outlining a recommended home-based exercise program and sent on their way to self-manage (or not).

The other group of 11 COPD patients joined a regional health network in their local area linked with a self-help association comprised of former pulmonary rehab graduates. With these resources at hand, the second group, denoted by the researchers as the "integrated care group" continued to go to exercise sessions at a local gym supervised by a trainer of sorts with experience in working with people who suffer from chronic disease (referred to in the study as a teacher of adapted physical activities). This second group also received periodic health education visits by representatives of the regional health network and periodic psychologist visits at a local community center.

The researchers evaluated the two groups' physical conditioning and quality of life ratings at 6 months and 12 months after graduation. The results of the two groups are very telling. For example, in one of the prime measures of exercise capacity, the six minute walk test (6MWT), patients from both groups saw their mean six minute walk distances (6MWD) rise at the end of the formal 4 week pulmonary rehab program by 45-52 meters (11-13% improvement) compared to their performance on a 6MWT at the beginning of the program.

However, 6 months and 12 months after graduating the formal rehab program, the "usual after care" group experienced an 8% DROP in 6MWD. In contrast, the "integrated care group" demonstrated an 8% RISE in 6MWD. What's driving the difference? In the researchers view, it is the ongoing commitment of support resources for the "integrated care group". And these same statistically significant differences were demonstrated in nearly all of the measured elements of the study – from perceived shortness of breath to peak exercise load to self-reported quality of life scores, and so on.

The practical reality is that providing these ongoing support resources in today's U.S. health care environment is difficult if not impossible from the standpoints of insurance reimbursement, practitioner capacity and facility capacity.

But what's the alternative? Send people off with a letter to go at it alone? Wait until the patient has a breathing exacerbation event that lands them back in the ER? Forget about them and move on to the next patient?

I don't think so, and I know many pulmonary rehab practitioners don't think so either. But until someone finds a way to dramatically broaden access and/or lower cost of providing pulmonary rehab type services (which, by the way, I'm working on one potential solution currently), graduating COPD patients have nowhere to turn and scant information to use to pursue a maintenance program on their own. My Breathe Better for Life guide/CD is a step in the right direction but it is only a step. Much more is needed if respiratory care professionals truly want to make a noticeable dent in helping people breathe better for the long term.

Thursday, December 31, 2009

Even a Simple Walking Program Can Improve Physical Conditioning for COPD Patients!

This month Portuguese researchers published the results of a study indicating that a pulmonary rehabilitation program built solely around a walking program (versus more intensive cardiovascular/strength training exercise typically found in rehab programs) produced improvements in several key measures of physical conditioning.

    For those who suffer from chronic shortness of breath and are not eligible for an outpatient pulmonary rehab program here in the United States and are reluctant to begin a cardiovascular/strength program on their own, this study highlights that conditioning benefits can be achieved by simply starting and maintaining a regular walking program.

The study, published in the Jornal brasileiro de pneumologia, took 16 COPD patients through a 7 week exercise program consisting of three 20 minute walking sessions each week (Ferreira SA, et al. Pulmonary Rehabilitation in COPD: from exercise training to "real life". J Bras Pneumol. 2009; (35) 11:1112-1115.) For those of you who are interested, the full text of the article can be viewed by clicking here.

Prior to the first walking session, researchers had each patient undergo a two separate 6 minute walk tests (known in pulmonary medicine circles as the 6MWT). Researchers also measured peak heart rate (pulse) during and after exercise, perceived breathlessness, aerterial blood gasses and patient self-reported changes in quality of life. The patients were all male with a mean age of 68. All had either Stage III or Stage IV COPD (moderate to severe, respectively), all were former smokers, and none were on home oxygen therapy.

A 6MWT is simply a mechanism used by physicians to establish a baseline and measure progress of a person's physical conditioning. During a 6MWT, patients simply walk as far as they can in a six minute period. Researchers measure the distance walked (known as the 6MWD) in either meters or yards.    

In this particular study, after the 7 week walking program was completed, researchers had the study subjects perform two additional 6WMT. The results? The mean distance walked by the 16 subjects rose on average 6-8%.

You might say that's not much of an improvement but consider the program only involved walking at a comfortable pace for 20 minutes 3 times a week for 7 weeks. Consider further that 31% of the patients reported an obvious improvement in their health (rising from moderate health status to good or very good health status). Further still, perceived breathlessness fell by an average of 11%. Heart rates measured during and after exercise also fell from the beginning of the study compared to the end.

The researchers concluded, "The exercise training protocol with walking resulted in improvement in quality of life and exercise capacity."

So, if nothing, get up and get walking! Your heart and lungs will thank you – even if you have COPD, even if you are an active or former smoker – exercise is powerful medicine!

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

New Hope For Smokers

Lung disease is pervasive - whether in America or in other countries around the globe. Smoking, environmental and workplace pollutants, poor diet and exercise habits, and in some cases genetic influences combine to make respiratory health a huge and growing issue just about in every society on our planet. And realistically, looking at the statistics and trends over the past few decades as well as future projections – the prognosis for combating compromised respiratory function is not promising. Despite all the valiant efforts of practitioners and researchers over the years, lung disease (including COPD, chronic bronchitis, asthma, emphysema and other more exotic conditions) continues to grow at alarming rates.

Contrast this picture to the inroads made by practitioners and researchers in the fields of cancer and heart disease and you get a clear sense of how bad things are now in the field of pulmonary medicine and how they are likely to worsen over time. The cost of not making significant progress in decreasing the incidence of pulmonary ailments is high and growing – not to mention frustrating for all concerned. One of the main reasons for this escalating cost cycle is that people with lung disease seem to land in hospitals over and over again. The solutions employed by physicians seem to lessen the immediate symptoms of these patients but candidly do very little to address the underlying problems that lead to this cycle.

Smoking cessation seems to be the first line of fire for addressing the largest contributing factor in the development of lung disease - understandably so given the clear benefits of stopping smoking at any age. But the data is clear – smoking cessation approaches of all stripes and combinations are not making much of a dent in the overall problem. Don't believe me? Last month, the Center for Disease Control issued a report stating that despite all the herculean efforts in marketing smoking cessation programs, new research and public service campaigns to reduce the incidence of smoking….smoking rates in the US have remained essentially flat over the past five years. http://www.cdc.gov/media/pressrel/2009/r091112.htm

I personally think a dramatic answer/solution to this problem is broad scale application of pulmonary rehabilitation. Specifically, I believe there would be significantly greater success in impacting long term smoking and lung disease trends if the $200 billion handed out to states over the past 10 years to combat smoking rates were instead applied to the following areas over the next 10 years:

  • Increasing awareness among smokers and those with lung disease about the power of pulmonary rehabilitation and how to incorporate its principles and practices into their daily lives.
  • Building more pulmonary rehabilitation programs around our country and making it easier for practitioners to offer and prospective patients to access
  • Introducing new, cost effective, innovative solutions to extend practitioners reach with this valuable treatment option

In my opinion, there is no doubt that the principles and practices of pulmonary rehabilitation persistently offered and maintained on a broader scale for anyone who is a smoker or suffers from any stage of nearly every lung disease could make a powerful impact on the direction of smoking cessation rates and overall lung disease in the U.S.

Will it happen? I don't know but I will continue to beat this drum and search for ways to get this wonderful treatment option in more people's hands.

Later this month comes my first stab at it – I will be introducing Breathe Better for Life™ - A Guide to the Secrets of Pulmonary Rehabilitation. It is my hope that I will be able to reach thousands (and even more hopefully, millions) of people in our country with this guide to educate them on the value of pulmonary rehabilitation and how to incorporate its principles and practices in their daily lives. I've read the research, been to several pulmonary rehab centers, talked to many of the leading practitioners & researchers, and visited with COPD patients who've been through such programs. And based on these experiences, I am convinced that a reprioritization of the standards of care for smokers and those with lung disease that puts pulmonary rehabilitation in front of smoking cessation could be the key to this elusive problem.